Why Evergreen Products Won’t Pay the Bills When You’re Starting Your Coaching Business

When new coaches first enter the industry, they often hear about the magic of evergreen products—courses, memberships, and digital downloads that supposedly generate passive income while they sleep. The problem? Evergreen products don’t pay the bills when you’re just starting out.

At I Love Coaching Co., we’ve seen too many new coaches invest months into building products before realizing they don’t yet have the audience or trust needed to sell them. The reality is that the most successful coaches start with high-touch, high-value services, then scale to evergreen once they’ve validated their audience.

Here’s why starting with premium, 1:1 coaching is the key to building a profitable coaching business.

Looking for your first clients? Start here.

Step 1: EMBARK — Start with High-Touch, High-Value Offers

When you’re launching your coaching business, your most valuable asset is personal connection. At this stage, your audience doesn’t know you well enough to buy a course or join a membership.

🚀 Why 1:1 Works First:

• Clients need to know, like, and trust you before they invest in something passive.

• Personal coaching lets you build credibility and showcase your transformation process.

• You can charge premium rates for 1:1 services, generating reliable income faster.

💡 Tactical Tip:

• Write down your ideal coaching scenario: Who are you helping? What transformation are they looking for? How do you best serve them directly? Use this clarity to build your 1:1 offer first.

Not sure how to price your 1:1 coaching? Here’s a complete guide.

Step 2: ENGAGE — Get to Know Your Clients First

Before diving into scalable products, validate your audience through direct, high-touch coaching. This means working with real people, in real conversations, to understand their struggles.

💡 Example:

One coach we worked with had built a membership site before landing any clients. After months of marketing and little success, she pivoted to 1:1 coaching, filled her client roster, and learned exactly what her ideal clients needed. Only then did she create a successful group program that was based on real client insights.

🚀 Try This:

• During your 1:1 sessions, take note of repeated pain points or common challenges. These are golden opportunities to build future group offers.

Still figuring out your niche? Here’s how to choose the right one.

Step 3: ENROLL — Add Scalable Products Only When the Foundation Is Strong

Once you’ve built a solid foundation with 5-10 paying clients and validated your niche, it’s time to think about scaling. Group coaching is often the next logical step because it allows you to leverage your time while still offering personalized support.

💪 Real Talk:

• Group coaching works because clients still get direct access to you, but with the added benefit of community support. It’s more scalable than 1:1 but less passive than evergreen products.

• Evergreen products should come after you’ve honed your messaging, built trust, and understood client needs.

Ready to make the transition? Here’s how to move from 1:1 to group coaching.

Why Evergreen Products Don’t Work for New Coaches

• High Upfront Investment: Building a course or membership site requires significant time and financial resources.

• Audience Trust Gap: If your clients haven’t experienced your transformation firsthand, they’re unlikely to invest in a self-paced product.

• Low Immediate ROI: Without a strong base of clients, evergreen products often fall flat because there’s no established demand.

💬 Story:

One coach we worked with spent 6 months creating an evergreen course before landing any clients. After launching, it barely sold because he hadn’t yet built an audience who trusted him. After pivoting to 1:1 coaching, he filled her roster within 2 months. Later, he built a course based on his client work, and it became his first successful passive income stream.

Final Thought:

Don’t be distracted by the allure of passive income before you have a solid coaching foundation. Start with 1:1 coaching, build trust, understand your clients, and then scale with confidence. Evergreen products can come later—when you know what your audience truly needs.

→ Join The REAL Deal Newsletter for weekly insights on building a sustainable, profitable coaching business.